I think Flacco is top 5 right now, based on the two good eyes I have. If you want to build a case based on the accomplishments of the past few years that five guys you listed are better, than so be it. Flacco has no rings, so if that's all your basing it on, the yeah, Joe is not top 5.
If I had to pick a QB for my team right now, just for this season, I probably go Rodgers, Brady, Old Manning, Roethlisberger, then Flacco.
LOL WTF? Not only do you have Rapelisberger at 4, but Flacco at 5? Can I have what you're smoking?
First thing, Drew Brees shits on both and should actually be #2 ahead of Brady and (Old) Manning. Then you have Eli who is also better than both and would be the 5th. If we are going on ability, then Matt Ryan, Vick, Newton, and Romo are all better than Rapelisberger and Flacco. But if we are going by playoff experience and crap like that, then I could say Flacco is in the same group as Mark Sanchez. And last I checked, Sanchez was one of the worst QBs in the league. Your move.
