UNI88 wrote:Chizzang wrote:
I understand free will (thank you)
I'm curious if you think free will and then God answering prayers are consistent..?
This is the "tennis without the net" game that Religions play
They love to throw around free will
but then insist that answering prayers and gods will and all that are common
When you ask about this - the response is blah blah blah "mysterious"
Well it's not very mysterious to me
any all powerful omnipotent entity that behaves like this god - is absolutely a monster
Explain how I'm wrong please
(please... I've been waiting years for somebody to simply explain)
I don't know. I haven't really thought about the conflict between free will and prayers being answered.
Bad stuff happens and there are a number of possible explanations:
- There is no god/gods
- God is a monster
- God has given us free will and some people are monsters.
Do we have free will if god intervenes? What if we asked him/her/it to intervene?
Well of course...
people that don't believe that god can be manipulated through prayer
don't tend to ponder the juxtaposition of free will and godly intervention
What purpose does free will serve if god can be coerced into answering requests
Here's the problem at it's core:
Would you buy a lottery ticket if you knew the lottery was rigged
but you didn't know who it was that had rigged the lottery
Would you buy a lottery ticket if you knew the lottery was rigged
and also knew exactly who rigged it and how it was rigged
Well this ^ is Religion and Free Will and Prayer...
If I can convince you I've rigged the lottery and how it's been rigged
It's pretty easy for me to sell you a lottery ticket at that point
