I'm surprised it's taken Krugman this long. "Lemon socialism" is a good term, although you could use it interchangeably with lemon capitalism.
Published on Wednesday, February 10, 2010 by the New York Times Oh. My. God. Obama Clueless
by Paul Krugman
The lead story on Bloomberg right now contains excerpts from an interview with Business Week which tells us:
President Barack Obama said he doesn't "begrudge" the $17 million bonus awarded to JPMorgan Chase & Co. Chief Executive Officer Jamie Dimon or the $9 million issued to Goldman Sachs Group Inc. CEO Lloyd Blankfein, noting that some athletes take home more pay.
The president, speaking in an interview, said in response to a question that while $17 million is "an extraordinary amount of money" for Main Street, "there are some baseball players who are making more than that and don't get to the World Series either, so I'm shocked by that as well."
"I know both those guys; they are very savvy businessmen," Obama said in the interview yesterday in the Oval Office with Bloomberg BusinessWeek, which will appear on newsstands Friday. "I, like most of the American people, don't begrudge people success or wealth. That is part of the free- market system."
Obama sought to combat perceptions that his administration is anti-business and trumpeted the influence corporate leaders have had on his economic policies. He plans to reiterate that message when he speaks to the Business Roundtable, which represents the heads of many of the biggest U.S. companies, on Feb. 24 in Washington.
Oh. My. God.
First of all, to my knowledge, irresponsible behavior by baseball players hasn't brought the world economy to the brink of collapse and cost millions of innocent Americans their jobs and/or houses.
The point is that these bank executives are not free agents who are earning big bucks in fair competition; they run companies that are essentially wards of the state. There's good reason to feel outraged at the growing appearance that we're running a system of lemon socialism, in which losses are public but gains are private. And at the very least, you would think that Obama would understand the importance of acknowledging public anger over what's happening.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:09 am
by ASUMountaineer
It just keeps getting better, and better. I bet the next three years (coupled with our excellent leadership in Congress) will be much improved.
I have to say, kalm, I'm not even surprised at this.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:10 am
by dbackjon
That was one of my biggest fears - that he was a good politician, but clueless to reality.
Still, better than McCain.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:12 am
by Appaholic
dbackjon wrote:That was one of my biggest fears - that he was a good politician, but clueless to reality.
Apparantly, no different than McCain.
fify...
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:12 am
by ASUMountaineer
dbackjon wrote:That was one of my biggest fears - that he was a good politician, but clueless to reality.
Still, better than McCain.
That's the point, Jon. THIS is the BEST we get to choose from? Something is going to have to change...but, I'm losing hope that much will ever change (I would like to thank Robert Gibbs for that one). The end of the Republic is not such a reckless notion anymore.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:14 am
by Appaholic
ASUMountaineer wrote: The end of the Republic is not such a reckless notion anymore.
Nor any more scary than the alternative.....
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:14 am
by Gil Dobie
dbackjon wrote:That was one of my biggest fears - that he was a good politician, but clueless to reality.
Still, better than McCain.
Better politican than Bush, but even more clueless than Bush. Obama still talks a good talk to come accross as more refined than Bush, but...............meet the new boss, same as the old boss
[youtube][/youtube]
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:18 am
by clenz
Hope and Change....
Don't actually change and damn thing you said you would, and hope no one notices.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:20 am
by AZGrizFan
dbackjon wrote:That was one of my biggest fears - that he was a good politician, but clueless to reality.
Still, better than McCain.
Jon, he's not even a good politician. He's a good CANDIDATE. He's a good CAMPAIGNER. And he's a hell of a SPEAKER. But he's NOT a good politician, and he IS clueless to reality. And NONE of those traits make him a better choice than McCain. NONE.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:26 am
by BlueHen86
AZGrizFan wrote:
dbackjon wrote:That was one of my biggest fears - that he was a good politician, but clueless to reality.
Still, better than McCain.
Jon, he's not even a good politician. He's a good CANDIDATE. He's a good CAMPAIGNER. And he's a hell of a SPEAKER. But he's NOT a good politician, and he IS clueless to reality. And NONE of those traits make him a better choice than McCain. NONE.
Exactly.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:29 am
by ASUMountaineer
Appaholic wrote:
ASUMountaineer wrote: The end of the Republic is not such a reckless notion anymore.
Nor any more scary than the alternative.....
Agreed.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:34 am
by Wedgebuster
Palin is the new hope for the future. Palin/Beck! Drill baby drill!!
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:41 am
by kalm
It's not even that the salaries are the problem. It's that these individuals remain in power and after more than a year into it we still don't have financial reform. When Sweden went through its economic crisis in the early nineties and had to temporarily nationalize their banks, the first thing they did was fire the management.
In the US they earn bonuses or become part of the president's economic team.
This has way more to do with campaign finance than anything else. Everyone should be beating the anti-corporatist drum at this point.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:47 am
by SeattleGriz
I have said for months that Obama has never known adversity, and thus is completely taken aback when his ideas don't work.
Think about it. Here is an Ivy league educated community organizer. Who would have ever dared to question anything he had done for being labeled as a racist. You question Obama, you are a racist. You question his efforts in the communities he was organizing, you are piece of shat that doesn't care about the less fortunate.
I think up until his Presidency, he felt he had the golden touch, and now is the first time he has ever seen any sort of backlash against his ideas. He doesn't know what to think. Couple that with the fact that most of his staff and his ideology are based in the world of academia and you have a group that doesn't know how the real World works.
In essence, I think political correctness was a major factor in why Obama got where he is and why he is so confused. If someone, somewhere along his way to the top had thrown some roadblocks up, he might be different.
Now, with all that being said, I cannot imagine myself being any different than Obama had I risen to the top so fast. Obama is a victim of his own success.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:52 am
by travelinman67
kalm wrote:It's not even that the salaries are the problem. It's that these individuals remain in power and after more than a year into it we still don't have financial reform. When Sweden went through its economic crisis in the early nineties and had to temporarily nationalize their banks, the first thing they did was fire the management.
In the US they earn bonuses or become part of the president's economic team.
This has way more to do with campaign finance than anything else. Everyone should be beating the anti-corporatist drum at this point.
The problem isn't the corporation, the problem is tort shield.
If I sell you a product that's defective, you can sue me for damages. If you win and I can't pay (or am underinsured), you become Chairman of the board. If Wall Street fails, unless fraud is proven, there's no tort. Return an index-based tort to Wall Street, allowing the shareholders, not the government, to indemnify themselves, and this shit would stop post haste.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:53 am
by kalm
SeattleGriz wrote:I have said for months that Obama has never known adversity, and thus is completely taken aback when his ideas don't work.
Think about it. Here is an Ivy league educated community organizer. Who would have ever dared to question anything he had done for being labeled as a racist. You question Obama, you are a racist. You question his efforts in the communities he was organizing, you are piece of shat that doesn't care about the less fortunate.
I think up until his Presidency, he felt he had the golden touch, and now is the first time he has ever seen any sort of backlash against his ideas. He doesn't know what to think. Couple that with the fact that most of his staff and his ideology are based in the world of academia and you have a group that doesn't know how the real World works.
In essence, I think political correctness was a major factor in why Obama got where he is and why he is so confused. If someone, somewhere along his way to the top had thrown some roadblocks up, he might be different.
Now, with all that being said, I cannot imagine myself being any different than Obama had I risen to the top so fast. Obama is a victim of his own success.
Interesting take, but I'm not sure you can say it was easy or that a black man didn't face adversity on his rise to become president. And I don't think you'd see much different from any other mainstream candidate. They are all slaves to their corporate masters (no pun intended)
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:54 am
by native
kalm wrote:It's not even that the salaries are the problem. It's that these individuals remain in power and after more than a year into it we still don't have financial reform. When Sweden went through its economic crisis in the early nineties and had to temporarily nationalize their banks, the first thing they did was fire the management.
In the US they earn bonuses or become part of the president's economic team.
This has way more to do with campaign finance than anything else. Everyone should be beating the anti-corporatist drum at this point.
The corporations are problematic, but not more so than the tax-and-spenders. Anti-corporatism will not solve the problems, it only entrenches the "political class" even deeper.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:57 am
by SeattleGriz
kalm wrote:Interesting take, but I'm not sure you can say it was easy or that a black man didn't face adversity on his rise to become president. And I don't think you'd see much different from any other mainstream candidate. They are all slaves to their corporate masters (no pun intended)
I'm not saying Obama sleep walked to where he is, but you have to admit his rise has been nothing short of meteoric. One would have to feel very confident in their abilities to be a President so quickly.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:58 am
by kalm
native wrote:
kalm wrote:It's not even that the salaries are the problem. It's that these individuals remain in power and after more than a year into it we still don't have financial reform. When Sweden went through its economic crisis in the early nineties and had to temporarily nationalize their banks, the first thing they did was fire the management.
In the US they earn bonuses or become part of the president's economic team.
This has way more to do with campaign finance than anything else. Everyone should be beating the anti-corporatist drum at this point.
The corporations are problematic, but not more so than the tax-and-spenders. Anti-corporatism will not solve the problems, it only entrenches the "political class" even deeper.
I have no problem with corporations as long they too are not receving welfare or become too big to fail. Regulation cannot happen unless corporate money is taken out of the election process.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 10:05 am
by native
kalm wrote:...
I have no problem with corporations as long they too are not receiving welfare or become too big to fail. Regulation cannot happen unless corporate money is taken out of the election process.
Concur about doing away with corporate welfare or thinking corporations too big to fail, but your solution is a chimera which will only make things worse by entrenching the political class more deeply.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 10:25 am
by Grizalltheway
So if he doesn't begrudge them their bonuses, he's clueless and out of touch, but if he WERE to begrudge them their bonuses, Z and company would be howling about how he's a commie. Wonderful logic there.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 10:31 am
by CitadelGrad
Grizalltheway wrote:So if he doesn't begrudge them their bonuses, he's clueless and out of touch, but if he WERE to begrudge them their bonuses, Z and company would be howling about how he's a commie. Wonderful logic there.
I think the real issue here is Obama's 180 for no apparent reason. It just reinforces my belief that he is an empty suit who says what he thinks will appeal to his immediate audience. He illustrates the difference between "politician" and "statesman" about as vividly as anyone I can remember.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 10:32 am
by SeattleGriz
Grizalltheway wrote:So if he doesn't begrudge them their bonuses, he's clueless and out of touch, but if he WERE to begrudge them their bonuses, Z and company would be howling about how he's a commie. Wonderful logic there.
Problem is, he already begrudged them their bonuses, and only now has flip flopped because he has seen what his rhetoric has done to Wall Street. He now realizes crapping on exec's is like cutting his nose off to spite his face.
Obama needs a strong Wall Street to get reelected.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 10:33 am
by AZGrizFan
Grizalltheway wrote:So if he doesn't begrudge them their bonuses, he's clueless and out of touch, but if he WERE to begrudge them their bonuses, Z and company would be howling about how he's a commie. Wonderful logic there.
GATW, you KNOW he's just pandering here. He SHOULDN'T begrudge them their bonuses.
The point is that these bank executives are not free agents who are earning big bucks in fair competition; they run companies that are essentially wards of the state. There's good reason to feel outraged at the growing appearance that we're running a system of lemon socialism, in which losses are public but gains are private.
THIS is the real issue in this article, because anyone with a brainstem figured out long ago that Obama was clueless, and it has nothing to do with his views on banking bonuses.
Re: Oh. My God. Obama is Clueless
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 10:55 am
by OL FU
Funny after reading him for a few years, I usually think Krugman is clueless