Page 1 of 1
How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:12 pm
by hank scorpio
What would you say a person in charge of the following should make?
$100,000,000 budget
5,000 employees
30 different properties to maintain
15,000 clients
Inquiring minds want to know.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:15 pm
by danefan
Is it a for-profit enterprise?
If so, what kind of margin is the company achieving?
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:18 pm
by hank scorpio
Not for profit
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:27 pm
by bobbythekidd
$350,000 with a SWEET bonus structure.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:43 pm
by danefan
bobbythekidd wrote:$350,000 with a SWEET bonus structure.
$250-$350 is what I was thinking too. I'm not sure about bonus structures in not-for-profits really.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:44 pm
by Pwns
$500,000 with incentives in contract if the person increases donations to the organization.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:45 pm
by danefan
danefan wrote:bobbythekidd wrote:$350,000 with a SWEET bonus structure.
$250-$350 is what I was thinking too. I'm not sure about bonus structures in not-for-profits really.
I'm editing my own guess. I misread the budget as being $10 million, not $100 million.
Something in the $500-$750 range seems more appropriate.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 4:54 pm
by Ivytalk
danefan wrote:danefan wrote:
$250-$350 is what I was thinking too. I'm not sure about bonus structures in not-for-profits really.
I'm editing my own guess. I misread the budget as being $10 million, not $100 million.
Something in the $500-$750 range seems more appropriate.
Gosh, danefan, that's almost as much as your draw!

Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 5:30 pm
by bobbythekidd
danefan wrote:bobbythekidd wrote:$350,000 with a SWEET bonus structure.
$250-$350 is what I was thinking too. I'm not sure about bonus structures in not-for-profits really.
Missed the non-profit part.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 6:09 pm
by ALPHAGRIZ1
$137,657 per year and some health care.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 7:00 pm
by danefan
Ivytalk wrote:danefan wrote:
I'm editing my own guess. I misread the budget as being $10 million, not $100 million.
Something in the $500-$750 range seems more appropriate.
Gosh, danefan, that's almost as much as your draw!

I wish. That's almost as much as my boss makes off my billables though.

:twisted\

Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2010 10:51 pm
by AZGrizFan
hank scorpio wrote:What would you say a person in charge of the following should make?
$100,000,000 budget
5,000 employees
30 different properties to maintain
15,000 clients
Inquiring minds want to know.
I'm thinkin' 7 figures. Minimum.

Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 8:35 am
by hank scorpio
Okay, this person is the Superintendent of Public Schools in the Billings area. The board is currently looking to replace the Jack Copps who is retiring after this school year.
Everybody was $250,000 and up except for the cheapass Alpha ($137,000).
The school board set the new salary between $140,000 - $165,000 per year, which is below or at the very most matches the regional average. So in reality they are going cheap. The public reaction has been very negative saying it is a waste of money. I think it is a sad indicator of the lack of support for schools in my hometown.
I guess we should hire some shmoe off of the street for $30,000 a year and call it good.

Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 8:46 am
by danefan
hank scorpio wrote:Okay, this person is the Superintendent of Public Schools in the Billings area. The board is currently looking to replace the Jack Copps who is retiring after this school year.
Everybody was $250,000 and up except for the cheapass Alpha ($137,000).
The school board set the new salary between $140,000 - $165,000 per year, which is below or at the very most matches the regional average. So in reality they are going cheap. The public reaction has been very negative saying it is a waste of money. I think it is a sad indicator of the lack of support for schools in my hometown.
I guess we should hire some shmoe off of the street for $30,000 a year and call it good.

No different than any other school district. In my area Superintendent's are making about $200,000. Underpaid IMO, especially having to deal with the teacher's union.
What's the enrollment in Billings? A $100 million seems very high.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 8:47 am
by hank scorpio
danefan wrote:hank scorpio wrote:Okay, this person is the Superintendent of Public Schools in the Billings area. The board is currently looking to replace the Jack Copps who is retiring after this school year.
Everybody was $250,000 and up except for the cheapass Alpha ($137,000).
The school board set the new salary between $140,000 - $165,000 per year, which is below or at the very most matches the regional average. So in reality they are going cheap. The public reaction has been very negative saying it is a waste of money. I think it is a sad indicator of the lack of support for schools in my hometown.
I guess we should hire some shmoe off of the street for $30,000 a year and call it good.

No different than any other school district. In my area Superintendent's are making about $200,000.
Underpaid IMO, especially having to deal with the teacher's union.
What's the enrollment in Billings? A $100 million seems very high.
+1
15,000
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 10:51 am
by Ursus A. Horribilis
hank scorpio wrote:Okay, this person is the Superintendent of Public Schools in the Billings area. The board is currently looking to replace the Jack Copps who is retiring after this school year.
Everybody was $250,000 and up except for the cheapass Alpha ($137,000).
The school board set the new salary between $140,000 - $165,000 per year, which is below or at the very most matches the regional average. So in reality they are going cheap. The public reaction has been very negative saying it is a waste of money. I think it is a sad indicator of the lack of support for schools in my hometown.
I guess we should hire some shmoe off of the street for $30,000 a year and call it good.

It's a rough situation with people wanting to pay guys in these positions and teachers for that matter. I know Jack personally and Billings is losing a real good man with his departure. Hopefully you guys can get a guy that wants to do the job because he is motivated by community/Montana pride because the pay isn't gonna be overwhelming by any means.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 11:03 am
by Appaholic
I don't have a problem paying a Supt really good money. My problem is most of them then go & hire about 20 Asst Supt's at 60k+car+living allowance....it's the bureacracy associated with school systems that manifests in anger towards a Supt's pay IMO...I mean, with all of the Asst Supt that a large school system has, what are we paying the Supt for? Would rather see the money go to teachers & Principals on the front line....
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 11:32 am
by Ursus A. Horribilis
Appaholic wrote:I don't have a problem paying a Supt really good money. My problem is most of them then go & hire about 20 Asst Supt's at 60k+car+living allowance....it's the bureacracy associated with school systems that manifests in anger towards a Supt's pay IMO...I mean, with all of the Asst Supt that a large school system has, what are we paying the Supt for? Would rather see the money go to teachers & Principals on the front line....
That's why it is too bad that Jack is leaving. He realized long ago the there was a big push back from voters and communities against new bond issues and taxes so he got involved trying to fix the waste or the perceived waste in the school districts after a long career in education and his first retirement. A guy like him is what you would want in that position.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Fri Feb 19, 2010 1:18 pm
by hank scorpio
Ursus A. Horribilis wrote:Appaholic wrote:I don't have a problem paying a Supt really good money. My problem is most of them then go & hire about 20 Asst Supt's at 60k+car+living allowance....it's the bureacracy associated with school systems that manifests in anger towards a Supt's pay IMO...I mean, with all of the Asst Supt that a large school system has, what are we paying the Supt for? Would rather see the money go to teachers & Principals on the front line....
That's why it is too bad that Jack is leaving. He realized long ago the there was a big push back from voters and communities against new bond issues and taxes so he got involved trying to fix the waste or the perceived waste in the school districts after a long career in education and his first retirement. A guy like him is what you would want in that position.

Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Sat Feb 20, 2010 7:20 am
by tribe_pride
By the way, that is a government entity and not a not-for-profit.
Re: How much should this person make?
Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 7:19 am
by mcveyrl
danefan wrote:bobbythekidd wrote:$350,000 with a SWEET bonus structure.
$250-$350 is what I was thinking too. I'm not sure about bonus structures in not-for-profits really.
Obviously this wouldn't apply here, but I'm on the board for our local symphony and our Exec. Dir. position has a bonus structure based on new donations brought in, with the caveat that the donations have to be traced back to the work of the director. Pretty difficult to do and, IMO, not worth for our smallish non-profit (less than 1,000,000 budget). But that's what we do.