Championship Subdivision Football | FCS Football | Stadiums | Blogs | Forums

Palestinian jailed for rape after claiming to be Jewish

A Palestinian man has been convicted of rape after having consensual sex with an Israeli woman who believed he was Jewish because he introduced himself as "Daniel".


By Adrian Blomfield in Jerusalem
Published: 10:00PM BST 20 Jul 2010

A court in Jerusalem has made international legal history by jailing Sabbar Kashur, a 30-year-old delivery man from East Jerusalem, for 18 months.

He was convicted of "rape by deception" following a criminal trial that has drawn criticism from across Israel.

The court heard accusations that Mr Kashur misled the woman, whose identity has not been disclosed, by introducing himself with the traditionally Jewish name during a chance encounter on a street in central Jerusalem in 2008.

After striking up a conversation, the two went into a top-floor room of a nearby office-block and engaged in a sexual encounter, after which Mr Kashur left before the woman had a chance to get dressed. It was only later that she discovered Mr Kashur's true racial background, lawyers said.

Although conceding that the sex was consensual, district court judge Tzvi Segal concluded that the law had a duty to protect women from "smooth-tongued criminals who can deceive innocent victims at an unbearable price"

"If she hadn't thought the accused was a Jewish bachelor interested in a serious romantic relationship, she would not have co-operated," Mrs Segal said as she delivered her verdict.

A conviction for rape by deception on the grounds of racial misrepresentation is believed to be internationally unprecedented, according to British legal experts.

The charge is rarely used in the West. In 2007, a Syrian pilot walked free from a court in Swansea after being accused of tricking a woman into intercourse by saying it could cure her of a sexually transmitted disease.

A court in Massachusetts also acquitted a man who allegedly masqueraded as his twin-brother in order to have sex with the man's wife.

While forced sex by deception is an offence under Israeli law, legal experts say it is a charge used sparingly in cases involving protracted deceit and a promise of marriage.

Kashur was originally accused of violent rape and indecent assault, but later accepted the lesser charge under a plea-bargain after prosecutors received evidence suggesting the encounter was consensual.

Kashur’s lawyer, Adnan Aladdin, said he had filed an appeal to ensure that the verdict was not considered precedent-setting, adding that otherwise “many men would find themselves in jail.”

Israeli legal experts said they found the verdict disquieting.

"In the context of Israeli society, you can see that some women would feel very strongly that they had been violated by someone who says he is Jewish but is not," said a former senior justice ministry official.

"The question is whether the state should punish somebody in that situation. It puts the law in the position of what could loosely be described as discrimination. I would feel intuitively uncomfortable about prosecuting someone for something like that."

Asked whether his client was the victim of racial discrimination, Mr Aladdin said he "would rather not comment". Others, however, were scathing.

Gideon Levy, a leading liberal commentator, said: "I would like to raise only one question with the judge. What if this guy had been a Jew who pretended to be a Muslim and had sex with a Muslim woman. Would he have been convicted of rape? The answer is: of course not."

Israeli human rights activists said that Kashur's actions reflected the deceits many Palestinians practise when in Israel in an attempt to avoid official and private prejudice because of their background.

"It is very well known that Israeli-Palestinians living in Israel disguise themselves," said Leah Tsemel, a human-rights lawyer. "You change your accent and you change your dress because if you look like an Arab you face harassment.

"If you want to enter a pub, you'd better not look like an Arab and if you want to have sex with an Israeli girl, you had better not look like an Arab."

The prosecutor in the case was unavailable for comment and officials in the Jerusalem district attorney's office declined to discuss it.

Rob Iola wrote:Isn't this a stoning offense in Iran? Seriously?

Rob Iola wrote:Isn't this a stoning offense in Iran? Seriously?

Skjellyfetti wrote:

Rob Iola wrote:Isn't this a stoning offense in Iran? Seriously?

What does that have to do with anything?

Do we give billions of dollars to Iran every year?

Col Hogan wrote:To answer the question posed by the thread title...NO, it is not rape...


Now I'm trying to figure out how we got from the question and the posted story...........all the way to how much money the U.S. government uses to support the state of Israel....

Pwns wrote:It's not rape, and it isn't theocracy so much as it is racism.

BlueHen86 wrote:What if the guy was a Christian?

Skjellyfetti wrote:

After striking up a conversation, the two went into a top-floor room of a nearby office-block and engaged in a sexual encounter, after which Mr Kashur left before the woman had a chance to get dressed. It was only later that she discovered Mr Kashur's true racial background, lawyers said.

"If she hadn't thought the accused was a Jewish bachelor interested in a serious romantic relationship, she would not have co-operated," Mrs Segal said as she delivered her verdict.

GannonFan wrote:No, it's not rape.

And no, this thread shouldn't have anything to do with how much we fund Israel.

ATrain wrote:

GannonFan wrote:No, it's not rape.

And no, this thread shouldn't have anything to do with how much we fund Israel.

+1 on both counts.
It was consensual sex between two consenting adults. If I end up having anal sex with a woman posing as a man (assuming it also happens in a completely darkened room), its not rape. We both consented, and its my fault for being stupid enough to not have any type of lighting to make sure I'm getting what I think I'm getting.

And one court case isn't at all justifiable for ceasing funding to Israel. They're the only relatively tolerant country in the Middle East and a good ally. If they had oil underneath their sands, they'd figure out a way to be worth more than Saudi Arabia and the UAE combined.

Skjellyfetti wrote:

A court in Massachusetts also acquitted a man who allegedly masqueraded as his twin-brother in order to have sex with the man's wife.

JohnStOnge wrote:Polsongriz, that is a horribly disturbing picture.

JohnStOnge wrote:Polsongriz, that is a horribly disturbing picture.

Skjellyfetti wrote:

Rob Iola wrote:Isn't this a stoning offense in Iran? Seriously?

What does that have to do with anything?

Do we give billions of dollars to Iran every year?