Can we stop the "It's not Islam" crap?
Posted: Thu May 23, 2013 4:51 pm
I know there's a thread on the London thing. But I'm focusing on one aspect of it that's a symptom of a larger phenomenon. It's that crap of being in denial about Islam itself being a factor.
After the "hack him up" attack in London, British Prime Minister David Cameron said this:
What a load of nonsense. Look, I know I'm big on not inferring cause and effect on the basis of observational data. But I've also said that you do reach a point where you don't need an experiment to know something is a causal factor. Like if you see a dog get hit by an 18 wheeler you know getting hit by the 18 wheeler caused the dog to die.
And Islam is CLEARLY a causal factor in this stuff. It's not just violent attacks like the one yesterday either. You look at most countries in which Islam has a majority of the population and they're persecuting people of other faiths. People of other faith are either consigned to second or third class citizenship or they are out and out physically attacked. Or both.
We have a principle of freedom of religion and that's a good principle. But at the same time it's not good to deny that a particular religion is a problem. And Islam is a problem. You may think other religions are problems too. But if they are Islam is a lot bigger one. A LOT bigger. It's not close.
After the "hack him up" attack in London, British Prime Minister David Cameron said this:
And he said:This was not just an attack on Britain and on the British way of life. It was also a betrayal of Islam and of the Muslim communities who give so much to our country
Stop. Just stop.There is nothing in Islam that justifies this truly dreadful act.
What a load of nonsense. Look, I know I'm big on not inferring cause and effect on the basis of observational data. But I've also said that you do reach a point where you don't need an experiment to know something is a causal factor. Like if you see a dog get hit by an 18 wheeler you know getting hit by the 18 wheeler caused the dog to die.
And Islam is CLEARLY a causal factor in this stuff. It's not just violent attacks like the one yesterday either. You look at most countries in which Islam has a majority of the population and they're persecuting people of other faiths. People of other faith are either consigned to second or third class citizenship or they are out and out physically attacked. Or both.
We have a principle of freedom of religion and that's a good principle. But at the same time it's not good to deny that a particular religion is a problem. And Islam is a problem. You may think other religions are problems too. But if they are Islam is a lot bigger one. A LOT bigger. It's not close.