Page 1 of 15
Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 8:36 am
by bluehenbillk
Are they kidding me?
The only people benefiting from this are businesses & people that don't make much money.
People filing married with incomes starting at $90k now are in the 25% tax bracket? The 25% tax bracket starts much higher than that now....that's going to piss off a lot of people. Make $260K & now it's 35%? Jesus.
They took the mortgage interest deduction away from people paying more than $500K on hosues - watch Toll Brothers stock plummet. The SALT deductions are going away or being slashed. Basically if you itemized deductions in the past chances are you just received a tax INCREASE.
Not a happy Trump voter right now....
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 8:42 am
by CID1990
bluehenbillk wrote:Are they kidding me?
The only people benefiting from this are businesses & people that don't make much money.
People filing married with incomes starting at $90k now are in the 25% tax bracket? The 25% tax bracket starts much higher than that now....that's going to piss off a lot of people. Make $260K & now it's 35%? Jesus.
They took the mortgage interest deduction away from people paying more than $500K on hosues - watch Toll Brothers stock plummet. The SALT deductions are going away or being slashed. Basically if you itemized deductions in the past chances are you just received a tax INCREASE.
Not a happy Trump voter right now....
Bubba, 5 dollars in the pocket of a WV coal miner is a lot like an Obama phone
He ain’t interested in you anyway
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 8:55 am
by ∞∞∞
On paper, I don't think it's that bad of a plan (except for the elimination of the estate tax)...but only if they figure out how to not balloon the deficit. Cutting corporate taxes is fine if it doesn't come at the expense of hurting programs that actually help people. But knowing the GOP, it will hurt people.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 8:56 am
by bandl
∞∞∞ wrote:I'm ok with cutting corporate taxes if it doesn't come at the expense of hurting social programs that actually help people.
You don't actually think that's a concern of theirs, do you?

Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 8:57 am
by ∞∞∞
bandl wrote:∞∞∞ wrote:I'm ok with cutting corporate taxes if it doesn't come at the expense of hurting social programs that actually help people.
You don't actually think that's a concern of theirs, do you?

I know it isn't.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:04 am
by bluehenbillk
Unless your family makes less than $90K in taxable income you're getting socked with an increase. If you're single & make more than $45K in taxable income you'll pay more.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:04 am
by Chizzang
bluehenbillk wrote:Are they kidding me?
The only people benefiting from this are businesses & people that don't make much money.
People filing married with incomes starting at $90k now are in the 25% tax bracket? The 25% tax bracket starts much higher than that now....that's going to piss off a lot of people. Make $260K & now it's 35%? Jesus.
They took the mortgage interest deduction away from people paying more than $500K on hosues - watch Toll Brothers stock plummet. The SALT deductions are going away or being slashed. Basically if you itemized deductions in the past chances are you just received a tax INCREASE.
Not a happy Trump voter right now....
Pardon me while I laugh my ass off
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:04 am
by 93henfan
As long as Bandel and Flaggy pay more taxes and I pay less, I will consider this a good plan.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:12 am
by bandl
93henfan wrote:As long as Bandel and Flaggy pay more taxes and I pay less, I will consider this a good plan.
Well we'll still be in the top tax bracket at 39.6%.
The elimination of the estate tax will benefit me.
As will the reduced corporate tax.
Maybe a wash until that estate transfer occurs.
EDIT: Yikes, I meant we'll be in the 35% tax bracket up from the 33% (i think?). It actually changes every year between the 28 & 33 bracket
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:23 am
by 93henfan
I will drop from the 28% bracket to the new 25%, so that’s a cool extra few thousand in my pocket. I’ll take it.
Now if they would include a provision whereby child support is deductible, I would do a little dance. If they also made the child support recipient have to report it as income, I’d spike the football.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:29 am
by Chizzang
93henfan wrote:I will drop from the 28% bracket to the new 25%, so that’s a cool extra few thousand in my pocket. I’ll take it.
Now if they would include a provision whereby child support is deductible, I would do a little dance. If they also made the child support recipient have to report it as income, I’d spike the football.
Explain why your taxes go from 28% to 25%

Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:29 am
by 93henfan
Chizzang wrote:93henfan wrote:I will drop from the 28% bracket to the new 25%, so that’s a cool extra few thousand in my pocket. I’ll take it.
Now if they would include a provision whereby child support is deductible, I would do a little dance. If they also made the child support recipient have to report it as income, I’d spike the football.
Explain why your taxes go from 28% to 25%

Because of the new brackets.
For individuals in 2016, the 28% bracket was $91,151-$190,150. Under the new plan, the 25% bracket is $45k-$200k.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:35 am
by bluehenbillk
93henfan wrote:I will drop from the 28% bracket to the new 25%, so that’s a cool extra few thousand in my pocket. I’ll take it.
Now if they would include a provision whereby child support is deductible, I would do a little dance. If they also made the child support recipient have to report it as income, I’d spike the football.
Do you itemize your deductions? If you answer yes that will pretty much eat up most, if not all of that 3%. They're trying to jam as many people as possible into the standard deduction.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:36 am
by Chizzang
93henfan wrote:Chizzang wrote:
Explain why your taxes go from 28% to 25%

Because of the new brackets.
For individuals in 2016, the 28% bracket was $91,151-$190,150. Under the new plan, the 25% bracket is $45k-$200k.
$45K to $200K is 25% now... I see said the blind prick
Also my taxes just went down from 35% to 20%
I love this new Trump guy, he's the best
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:42 am
by 93henfan
bluehenbillk wrote:93henfan wrote:I will drop from the 28% bracket to the new 25%, so that’s a cool extra few thousand in my pocket. I’ll take it.
Now if they would include a provision whereby child support is deductible, I would do a little dance. If they also made the child support recipient have to report it as income, I’d spike the football.
Do you itemize your deductions? If you answer yes that will pretty much eat up most, if not all of that 3%. They're trying to jam as many people as possible into the standard deduction.
Nope. Standard deduction and that’s doubling, so even more money in my pocket.
I’ve been getting $5k returns the past few years, so I’d expect $10k-ish under the new plan.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 9:58 am
by bluehenbillk
So you live in an apartment?
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 10:03 am
by 93henfan
bluehenbillk wrote:So you live in an apartment?
Essentially. I rent my parents’ second house from them. Actually it’s my house now, because they added me to their family trust earlier this year. So, I rent a house from me, my parents, and my sister.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 10:12 am
by bluehenbillk
Makes sense... the majority of us will suffer. Regretting we didn't have a better choice a year ago..
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 10:45 am
by HI54UNI
Chart showing the brackets in this article.
http://www.businessinsider.com/trump-go ... m=referral
If I did my math correctly a married couple filing jointly with taxable income (income after whatever deductions they qualify for) of $200K sees their tax bill go down about $4,600. Same couple with $100K taxable income saves about $3,200.
Big question is how the various deductions impact you to get to your taxable income.
Our house is about paid for so our mortgage interest deduction was small enough that itemizing isn't much more than the standard deduction. I should come out pretty well on this.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 10:51 am
by HI54UNI
Many components of the bill appear to be a big FU to the blue states.

Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 10:55 am
by ∞∞∞
HI54UNI wrote:Many components of the bill appear to be a big FU to the blue states.

So an FU to most states that aren't federal dependents?
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 10:59 am
by HI54UNI
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 11:23 am
by bluehenbillk
HI54UNI wrote:
If I did my math correctly a married couple filing jointly with taxable income (income after whatever deductions they qualify for) of $200K sees their tax bill go down about $4,600. Same couple with $100K taxable income saves about $3,200.
You must've learned the "new math" they teach in schools nowadays. No idea how you come up with those #'s. If you lived for filling out Schedule A (like I did to the tune of around $35K last year) you're in for a sick wake-up call.
Personal exemptions - gone
Healthcare exemptions - gone
State & local income exemptions - gone
What stays:
Mortgage interest - unless you're house was over $500K (but if you take the doubled standard deduction this is gone too)
Property tax deduction - up to $10K, but again if you take the doubled standard deduction this is gone to)
Charitable giving
So the bottom line - if you claimed more than $24,000 on Schedule A last year you're screwed, because you can no longer itemize deductions
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 11:34 am
by bluehenbillk
I'll add one thing that's a positive that I just read. The Child Tax Credit which know maxes at about $140K of income give or take is morphed into the Family Tax Credit which maxes instead at around $230K & has a max credit of $1,600 per child versus the old $1,000 per.
Re: Tax Bill is a loser
Posted: Thu Nov 02, 2017 11:51 am
by 93henfan
The disappointing part of all of this is that it doesn’t really do anything to simplify the tax code. These changes shrink it from about 73,954 pages to maybe 73,950.
Yay.