Understand that I WANT Ohio State in the playoff. I think it's a team that has the horses to take on Alabama. I think the thing with Ohio State is being focused and ready to play and I think if they're playing Alabama that won't be a problem. Ohio State, I think, is clearly more talented than Penn State or Wisconsin. Also, when you just look at the records and such they're a better team than either Penn State or Wisconsin.
BUT...take a look at the protocol at
http://d30ratpzqzalg7.cloudfront.net/CD ... mkEd00PiAY
I looked it up thinking it'd support my view that a conference championship is just one of many factors and not that important. But when I saw it I saw that that's not the case. Here's one paragraph I think is particularly interesting:
Underline added for emphasis.We believe that a committee of experts properly instructed (based on beliefs that the regular season is
unique and must be preserved; and that championships won on the field and strength of schedule are
important values that must be incorporated into the selection process) has very strong support
throughout the college football community.
Under the current construct, polls (although well-intended) have not expressed these values; particularly
at the margins where teams that have won head-to-head competition and championships are sometimes
ranked behind non-champions and teams that have lost in head-to-head competition. Nuanced
mathematical formulas ignore some teams who “deserve” to be selected.
I gotta say I will be glad if Ohio State is in and think that if the objective is to make the best effort to select the four best teams Ohio State SHOULD be in. But they do appear to be kind of contradicting themselves.