Championship Subdivision Football | FCS Football | Stadiums | Blogs | Forums

as the title states:
for Southern some people say the best coach was A.W. Mumford (179-61-13 in 25 years) but since I wasn't around then my vote goes to Pete Richardson (135-61 in 17 years) he turned around a mediocre program and had a few teams that could have at least made the playoffs (1993, 1995, 1997, 1999, and maybe 2003) won SWAC 5 times and had a nine game win streak over Grambling.

Worst coach was Gerald Kimble (14-18-1 in 3 years) now there might have been coaches with worse records but I think it says something when you are better as a PA announcer than as a coach.

I am looking directly at you Alpha....


I don't want one bitter ass-clown Griz fan to post that Bobby Hauck was the worst in school history.

KC is only the Hens fourth coach since 1940.

Worst coaches had to be the two prior to the Murray-Nelson-Raymond era, who were the best...

Lyal W. Clark 1935-37: 5-18-1 .230
Stephen J. Grenda 1938-39: 4-12-0 .250
William D. Murray 1940-50: 49-16-2 .747
David M. Nelson 1951-65: 84-42-2 .664
Harold R. "Tubby" Raymond 1966-2001: 300-119-3 .714
Kurt C. "K.C." Keeler 2002-Present: 62-39 .614

Best would have to go to Mickey since he won the National Championship, but Dukes' fans would be remiss not to strongly consider the program's first coach, Callace McMillin. Not only did he serve as head coach and build the foundation for the program, but he also coached our most successful pros and still serves as the sports psychologist for JMU athletics.

Worst - Alex Wood. No doubt in my mind. He had a horrible record and every player account I've heard on him is that he was a grade A a-hole to his players. When he left he promised his team he'd be a coach in the NFL in a couple of years...

GSU:

Best: Erk Russell... started the program from scratch and won 3 NC's (including 15-0-0 in 1989) and 1 runner-up in 8 years, also set the 1-AA/FCS home winning streak record. Honorable mention to Paul Johnson, who won 2 NC's and 1 runner-up in 5 years.

Worst: Brian Van Gorder... nuked the program's famed triple option offense and went 3-8 in his only year before hightailing it out of town only 12 days before Nat'l Signing Day.

Well no Griz fan can argue that Don Read (86-95) was our best. He basically built our program with an unstoppable aerial offense

Worst, someone from before my time, back when we sucked (which was most of the time)

Silenoz wrote:Well no Griz fan can argue that Don Read (86-95) was our best. He basically built our program with an unstoppable aerial offense

Worst, someone from before my time, back when we sucked (which was most of the time)

Yeah, I think when they decide to name the main street around campus after the guy, that pretty much settles it.

Best: Bob Mattos, 1978-1992 (Passed away last year at the age of 68) RIP. Wiinningest coach in school history, led the 1988 team to the DII playoffs where the Hornets won their first two games. An amazing man and coach.

Worst: Steve Mooshagian, 2003-2006 (Worst coach EVER!). This guy did absolutely nothing during his short tenure, except complain.

Best is Jerry Moore. Longest tenured coach by a mile. 3 National Titles. 21 years at App with a .79 win percentage is pretty impressive.

Not sure who the worst is. There are a few with short tenures and bad records, but I don't know enough about them to say who the worst is.

And, off topic question for a Wofford fan... was Bob Breitenstein... Appalachian's coach in 1959... Eric Breitenstein's grandfather? I knew Eric was from the Boone area and saw that name on the list of App's coaches and got curious.

Best- Tie between Terry Allen and Mark Farley.

Worst- Mike Dunbar, really the only coach that couldn't win at UNI.

Montana State

Best: Sonny Holland, 1971 - 1977 two Big Sky Championships 72 & 76 and one DII National Title 1976. Overall record 47-27

Worst: Earl Solomonson, 1987 - 1991 overall record 15-40. Set program back many years that we are still trying to recover from in some areas in Montana.

Honorable Mention to Sonny Lubick. Didn't have a steller record, but did win a Big Sky Championship in 1979 and it was his recruits that won the National Title in 1984. Jury is still out on Rob Ash. Like what we are seeing so far, but time will tell.

canyoncat wrote:Montana State

Best: Sonny Holland, 1971 - 1977 two Big Sky Championships 72 & 76 and one DII National Title 1976. Overall record 47-27

Worst: Earl Solomonson, 1987 - 1991 overall record 15-40. Set program back many years that we are still trying to recover from in some areas in Montana.

Honorable Mention to Sonny Lubick. Didn't have a steller record, but did win a Big Sky Championship in 1979 and it was his recruits that won the National Title in 1984. Jury is still out on Rob Ash. Like what we are seeing so far, but time will tell.

Can you please elaborate? I am not familiar with this name and the damage he did to MSU.

Best, Joe Glenn, Back to back d-II National Championships in 1996 and 1997

Worst, Scott Downing, Nice guy but couldn't beat an egg even with the proper instructions.

DJH wrote:Best- Tie between Terry Allen and Mark Farley.

Worst- Mike Dunbar, really the only coach that couldn't win at UNI.

Dunbar still went 7-4, 7-4, 8-3, 7-4. The fact he didn't get us to the playoffs is what hurts his reputation at UNI. If we get to the playoffs even twice during his time he is looked at in a much different light. But yeah, he is probably the "worst" coach we have had, then again he was the coach last time we lost to Youngstown.

I'd at Darrell "Dr. Victory" Mudra to the best list. 43–16–1 during his time at UNI, was the coach during the D1 transition and led UNI to two semi final appearances in our first three years of D1.

Cap and D can tell us more about him though

grizzaholic wrote:

canyoncat wrote:Montana State

Best: Sonny Holland, 1971 - 1977 two Big Sky Championships 72 & 76 and one DII National Title 1976. Overall record 47-27

Worst: Earl Solomonson, 1987 - 1991 overall record 15-40. Set program back many years that we are still trying to recover from in some areas in Montana.

Honorable Mention to Sonny Lubick. Didn't have a steller record, but did win a Big Sky Championship in 1979 and it was his recruits that won the National Title in 1984. Jury is still out on Rob Ash. Like what we are seeing so far, but time will tell.

Can you please elaborate? I am not familiar with this name and the damage he did to MSU.

Said that there were no athletes good enough in the state of Montana. Pissed off a ton of alumni. Brought in and tried to run an option offense with a pass first offense in a passing conference. Just a shit poor recruiter.

Old Dominion
Best Coach: Bobby Wilder 2009-Present 13-5
Worst Coach: Bobby Wilder 2009-Present 13-5

Even though he was before my time I think I speak for a lot of Flames fans when I say that the best coach in our history was Sam Rutigliano. All time winningest coach in school history and led LU to its highest national ranking in school history and probably the closest they ever had been to the playoffs until the Big South qualified for an autobid this year. WOrst...probably Ken Karcher. 1 winning season in his time on the mountain and if not for Danny Rocco I think it would have set us back a number of years

canyoncat wrote:

grizzaholic wrote:
Can you please elaborate? I am not familiar with this name and the damage he did to MSU.

Said that there were no athletes good enough in the state of Montana. Pissed off a ton of alumni. Brought in and tried to run an option offense with a pass first offense in a passing conference. Just a shit poor recruiter.

Thank you.

canyoncat wrote:Montana State

Best: Sonny Holland, 1971 - 1977 two Big Sky Championships 72 & 76 and one DII National Title 1976. Overall record 47-27

Worst: Earl Solomonson, 1987 - 1991 overall record 15-40. Set program back many years that we are still trying to recover from in some areas in Montana.

Honorable Mention to Sonny Lubick. Didn't have a steller record, but did win a Big Sky Championship in 1979 and it was his recruits that won the National Title in 1984. Jury is still out on Rob Ash. Like what we are seeing so far, but time will tell.

Totally agree but I have a 2nd Honorable Mention for Dave Arnold who could be considered ,in a 3 year period, to be both.

1983 1-10
1984 12-2 National Championship
1985 2-9

Worst GSU coach? I'll have to think about that one for a few days and get back to you.

Catattack wrote:

canyoncat wrote:Montana State

Best: Sonny Holland, 1971 - 1977 two Big Sky Championships 72 & 76 and one DII National Title 1976. Overall record 47-27

Worst: Earl Solomonson, 1987 - 1991 overall record 15-40. Set program back many years that we are still trying to recover from in some areas in Montana.

Honorable Mention to Sonny Lubick. Didn't have a steller record, but did win a Big Sky Championship in 1979 and it was his recruits that won the National Title in 1984. Jury is still out on Rob Ash. Like what we are seeing so far, but time will tell.

Totally agree but I have a 2nd Honorable Mention for Dave Arnold who could be considered ,in a 3 year period, to be both.

1983 1-10
1984 12-2 National Championship
1985 2-9

Honorable and Dishonorable

Easy for Albany:
Bob Ford


and Doctor Robert Ford

canyoncat wrote:Totally agree but I have a 2nd Honorable Mention for Dave Arnold who could be considered ,in a 3 year period, to be both.

1983 1-10
1984 12-2 National Championship
1985 2-9

How do you go from 1-10, to National Championship, to sucking again? Awesome!

Rich Kotite.

NDSU

Gil Dobie was undefeated but was only there a couple years, so the best coach would be Darrell Mudra, who turned the program around in the early 1960's and won the first of 8 National Championships.

Worst record was Del Anderson 1-16-1 in 1954-55 seasons.


PS: Even Darrell Mudra couldn't win a championship at UNI