Championship Subdivision Football | FCS Football | Stadiums | Blogs | Forums

Ahoy landlubbers! Scribe yur comments here. Tha show ta be aired at 10AM Eastern. Yar!

So what is going on??? Leathernecks had a great day yesterday!



jc

MFVC get 3 teams.

WIU at Coastal winner plays App St
RMU at NDSU winner plays Montana St

App State #1 seed.

A home game for NDst. thats great! Barr and company will really enjoy the weather in Carolina!

It appears that WIU got in over SC State (figuring that a matchup would lead to playing App in round 2), unless we get SCSU/Wofford.

Gil Dobie wrote:MFVC get 3 teams.

WIU at Coastal winner plays App St
RMU at NDSU winner plays Montana St

Lehigh at UNI

Lol ok well my brackets are out the window. Didn't see that coming

Gil Dobie wrote:

Gil Dobie wrote:MFVC get 3 teams.

WIU at Coastal winner plays App St
RMU at NDSU winner plays Montana St

Lehigh at UNI

Lehigh/UNI winner at Delaware

There are teams that belong in ahead of LU.

SCSU isn't one of them.

This is a joke. Total, absolute joke.

Some of this seems off to me not only does NDSU get in .... They get a home game?

ToTheLeft wrote:There are teams that belong in ahead of LU.

SCSU isn't one of them.

This is a joke. Total, absolute joke.

Actually I have seen both teams play a lot this year and I would go with SC State. They have a much better defense and we all know defense wins championships. If they had Mike Brown and Chris Summers on their team they would have been the MEAC AQ and likely a top 6 team. Their defense will keep them in the game with GSU. I have no beef with SCSU getting in. I have them ranked ahead of Liberty. Remember, Liberty has a loss to JMU who went 6-5 in CAA and did not get in either.

SmallCollegeFBFan wrote:

ToTheLeft wrote:There are teams that belong in ahead of LU.

SCSU isn't one of them.

This is a joke. Total, absolute joke.

Actually I have seen both teams play a lot this year and I would go with SC State. They have a much better defense and we all know defense wins championships. If they had Mike Brown and Chris Summers on their team they would have been the MEAC AQ and likely a top 6 team. Their defense will keep them in the game with GSU. I have no beef with SCSU getting in. I have them ranked ahead of Liberty. Remember, Liberty has a loss to JMU who went 6-5 in CAA and did not get in either.

DEFENSE IS NOT A CRITERIA.

Whatever, no one can convince me on this one. There are teams that belong in ahead of us. Not SCSU. No one can convince me.

CPAlum wrote:Some of this seems off to me not only does NDSU get in .... They get a home game?

Once you are in, money talks for the first round home games.

CPAlum wrote:Some of this seems off to me not only does NDSU get in .... They get a home game?

home games are determined by bids (i.e. $$$$$), not by record. (other than teams that earn a top-5 seed)

SC State? The worst conference in all of Division 1 got two teams in? And here I am bitching about the BCS.

Oh well...that's my only qualm. The rest seems fine.

I don't think there's any question what the game of the week for the opening round is.

∞∞∞ wrote:SC State? The worst conference in all of Division 1 got two teams in? And here I am bitching about the BCS.

Oh well...that's my only qualm. The rest seems fine.

Seriously, put in JMU or Montana. They did more to earn it.

SCSU doesn't deserve it at all. LU was robbed. This is a joke.

ToTheLeft wrote:

SmallCollegeFBFan wrote:
Actually I have seen both teams play a lot this year and I would go with SC State. They have a much better defense and we all know defense wins championships. If they had Mike Brown and Chris Summers on their team they would have been the MEAC AQ and likely a top 6 team. Their defense will keep them in the game with GSU. I have no beef with SCSU getting in. I have them ranked ahead of Liberty. Remember, Liberty has a loss to JMU who went 6-5 in CAA and did not get in either.

DEFENSE IS NOT A CRITERIA.

Whatever, no one can convince me on this one. There are teams that belong in ahead of us. Not SCSU. No one can convince me.

SC St is 9-2
Liberty is 8-3

SC St has played well in the playoffs recently. That may have factored into which conference (MEAC or Big South) was more deserving of a second bid this year.

The bracket:

http://grfx.cstv.com/photos/schools/nca ... racket.pdf

Big Sky got shafted with the seeding, and forced a rematch in the quarters, ensuring only one can reach the semis. Shocking.

JayJ79 wrote:

CPAlum wrote:Some of this seems off to me not only does NDSU get in .... They get a home game?

home games are determined by bids (i.e. $$$$$), not by record. (other than teams that earn a top-5 seed)

I expected that NDSU would get in and get a home game (unless their first round game was Montana, which it isn't).

BlueHen86 wrote:

ToTheLeft wrote:
DEFENSE IS NOT A CRITERIA.

Whatever, no one can convince me on this one. There are teams that belong in ahead of us. Not SCSU. No one can convince me.

SC St is 9-2
Liberty is 8-3

SC St has played well in the playoffs recently. That may have factored into which conference (MEAC or Big South) was more deserving of a second bid this year.

SC St. is EIGHT and TWO. Not an all DI schedule.

They had no wins worth ANYTHING and the loss to B-CU is bad in the computers, but apparently the committee was infatuated with the worst conference in football, since B-CU got a bye.

I guess the money the MEAC brings trumps resume. Just put Montana in in that case.

And if recent history played into it, then I'm done with this stupid system.

Screamin_Eagle174 wrote:Big Sky got shafted with the seeding, and forced a rematch in the quarters, ensuring only one can reach the semis. Shocking.

If NDSU or RMU doesn't pull a Northern Arizona on Montana St.

Screamin_Eagle174 wrote:Big Sky got shafted with the seeding, and forced a rematch in the quarters, ensuring only one can reach the semis. Shocking.

Based on a Montanaless Big Sky playoff field.. I'd be a lot more concerned winning a game than reaching the semis...