Championship Subdivision Football | FCS Football | Stadiums | Blogs | Forums

Eagles get Rogers-Cromartie & a #2 for Kolb, who gets a $63M contract extension from AZ.

bluehenbillk wrote:Eagles get Rogers-Cromartie & a #2 for Kolb, who gets a $63M contract extension from AZ.

eagles shoulda kept Kolb, and dumped Vick.

Not happy

DJH wrote:eagles shoulda kept Kolb, and dumped Vick.

IMO Vick can win games, Kolb is a QB that can just help you avoid losing games. Vick should have 2-4 more good years in him, so they should be OK for now.

dbackjon wrote:Not happy

I think he's better than what you had.

Vick will win games, but not championships.

DJH wrote:Vick will win games, but not championships.

Kolb won't do either.

89Hen wrote:

dbackjon wrote:Not happy

I think he's better than what you had.

Not at the cost of a pro-bowler,and 2nd Round pick

Maybe, maybe not. But how do you know? He only has played a few games. You know what you are going to get with Vick, and he has a ceiling.

dbackjon wrote:

89Hen wrote: I think he's better than what you had.

Not at the cost of a pro-bowler,and 2nd Round pick

You gotta have a QB. You can replace defensive backs, but if you don't have a QB you are done in the NFL.

I think its a good move to take a chance like this on a guy like Kolb. Especially for Az, who has nobody to play QB.

DJH wrote:Maybe, maybe not. But how do you know? He only has played a few games. You know what you are going to get with Vick, and he has a ceiling.

It's a guess based on what I have seen. I've definitely been wrong about drop back passers before though. I can tell you that I was horrified at the prospect of Matt Schaub leading UVA his senior season. He looked like crap prior to that year. Now he's a top 10 QB in the NFL.

I was right on McNabb being a bust last year though.

DJH wrote:

dbackjon wrote:

Not at the cost of a pro-bowler,and 2nd Round pick

You gotta have a QB. You can replace defensive backs, but if you don't have a QB you are done in the NFL.

I think its a good move to take a chance like this on a guy like Kolb. Especially for Az, who has nobody to play QB.

Orton.

Hell, Skelton is almost as proven as Kolb

dbackjon wrote:

DJH wrote:
You gotta have a QB. You can replace defensive backs, but if you don't have a QB you are done in the NFL.

I think its a good move to take a chance like this on a guy like Kolb. Especially for Az, who has nobody to play QB.

Orton.

Hell, Skelton is almost as proven as Kolb

Kolb is greater than Skelton and Orton put together. That being said, I see NO reason to have thrown in a #2 pick with DRC.

I think Kolb will play well for the Cards, but I doubt they'll be a deep playoff team.

Kyle Orton? The ESPN jaggoffs were slobbing the guy's knob earlier in the week saying Miami had to have him. I guess I don't understand what everyone sees in him.

89Hen wrote:

DJH wrote:eagles shoulda kept Kolb, and dumped Vick.

IMO Vick can win games, Kolb is a QB that can just help you avoid losing games. Vick should have 2-4 more good years in him, so they should be OK for now.