CAA Flagship wrote:93henfan wrote:The numbers are what they are.
Agree, but Buddy Ryan wasn't much of an offensive genius. Cunningham likely had to earn his stats a bit more than McNabb. I really don't have an opinion on which one was better, btw.
No doubt. One coach made his name as a DC and for his 46 defense. The other made his name being Brett Favre's QB coach in Green Bay.
Which would any QB rather start for?
And I think Randall would have been a far better QB with a coach who didn't basically say, "I'll focus on the defense and let #12 do whatever he does on the other side of the ball." I'm paraphrasing, but Buddy made comments to that effect many times over the years.
Not to mention, Donovan McNabb couldn't punt: