Does App St. come off a loss and move up to #1?

[SeattleGriz]

Ah what the hell, make the two Big Sky teams 1 and 2. It's not like they'll still be there to host in the semis anyway.

Well, if we could get the usual NEC or Patriot patsy's the CAA gets, then YOU BET!

Always love the first round gimme handed to the top two CAA teams.

A warm up game is always nice.

[BDKJMU]

No. App got completely handled today.

As much as I wanted to see them do well (to gauge UM vs UT next year), they got their asses handed to them.

They should drop because they showed no ability to stop a sub par SEC team (that of course is what the ASU fans were saying before the game).

Whats worse, a 27 point loss to NAU or a 38 point loss to UF?

[Skjellyfetti]

Florida is hardly a "sub par SEC team." They're 2nd in the Eastern Division.

[BTG Go CATS Go]

it wont matter the bracket will be made and thats the only thing that will matter

[SeattleGriz]

Florida is hardly a "sub par SEC team." They're 2nd in the Eastern Division.

How convenient. A week ago, ASU was gonna give UF the game of their lives, now, once getting their ass handed to them, UF is a stellar team.

By the way, I thought ASU looked good most of the game, just outmatched as expected.

I am not looking to get into a pissing match here SK, just bitter Montana lost while bringing up some very loft talk by ASU this last week.

[dbackjon]

Florida is hardly a "sub par SEC team." They're 2nd in the Eastern Division.

Which rivals the ACC or Big East for suckage.

[CrackerRiley]

Florida is hardly a "sub par SEC team." They're 2nd in the Eastern Division.

Which rivals the ACC or Big East for suckage.

relative to what?

[dbackjon]

Which rivals the ACC or Big East for suckage.

relative to what?

BCS conferences/divisions. SEC East is horrible (for a BCS conference/division) this year

[ChickenMan]

1.. I can't see how ASU moves up after losing by 38 points to a four loss Florida team.
2.. I can't see how UD stays the #1 seed after losing in OT to Nova,
3.. I can't see W&M being the #1 seed with three loses.. two to non playoff teams
4.. I can't see EWU being the #1 seed with a 23 point loss to Montana St
5.. I can't see Montana St being a high seed with a 27 point loss to unranked NAU
6.. I can't see SFA being a #1 seed with a loss to a 4-7 Texas St

so no one deserves the top seed,, but someone will get it. My seed predictions;

1.. ASU as deserving as anyone else.. plus $$$ are always a hidden factor
2.. UD two loses to playoff teams.. the first by a point.. the other in OT and the $$$ factor
3.. SFA bad loss to Texas St drops them below UD
4.. W&M loses to non playoffs UMass and JMU offsets win over UD
5.. Montana St over EWU

[93henfan]

1.. I can't see how ASU moves up after losing by 38 points to a four loss Florida team.
2.. I can't see how UD stays the #1 seed after losing in OT to Nova,
3.. I can't see W&M being the #1 seed with three loses.. two to non playoff teams
4.. I can't see EWU being the #1 seed with a 23 point loss to Montana St
5.. I can't see Montana St being a high seed with a 27 point loss to unranked NAU
6.. I can't see SFA being a #1 seed with a loss to a 4-7 Texas St

so no one deserves the top seed,, but someone will get it. My seed predictions;

1.. ASU as deserving as anyone else.. plus $$$ are always a hidden factor
2.. UD two loses to playoff teams.. the first by a point.. the other in OT and the $$$ factor
3.. SFA bad loss to Texas St drops them below UD
4.. W&M loses to non playoffs UMass and JMU offsets win over UD
5.. Montana St over EWU

I bet that was a very insightful post, but all I saw was thong.

[Appaholic]

NOPE! WE ALL KNOW THAT EASTERN WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY IS THE NEW #1 ! Fair is Fair is Fair.

BWAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAA EWU BWAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHH!!!!

[Appaholic]

Eastern Washington was #3. #2 & #1 lost. Therefor making #3 fall to #1. App st gets a pass just bc its florida???? Eastern lost to ~#23 UNR.. If it says 'L', then u lost muffucka.

#3 to #4 seed?!?

BWAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAA EWU BWAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHH!!!!

BWAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAA EWU BWAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHH!!!!

[Ivytalk]

I had EWU as #1 in my poll after Saturday. I just couldn't "promote" App State after that defeat.

[Appaholic]

I had EWU as #1 in my poll after Saturday. I just couldn't "promote" App State after that defeat.

Actually, I would have to but still enjoy BF's taking one for the team....

[93henfan]

To succinctly answer the question posed in the thread title:

Yes.

[Screamin_Eagle174]

To succinctly answer the question posed in the thread title:

Yes.

I'm pretty sure the question posed in the thread title was referring to #1 in the polls. So the answer is no.

[SuperHornet]

I'm good with Appy as the 1 seed. But what I'm NOT good with is Delaware dropping two spots off of one loss. Delaware should be the 2 seed.

I know that doesn't mean much in terms of making the semis. But it DOES mean that they won't have the home-field advantage that they EARNED through the season (unless Bill loses early, which is certainly a possibility given that they'll have to play Jax St or Wofford). That COULD mean something in the semis.

[Screamin_Eagle174]

I'm good with Appy as the 1 seed. But what I'm NOT good with is Delaware dropping two spots off of one loss. Delaware should be the 2 seed.

I know that doesn't mean much in terms of making the semis. But it DOES mean that they won't have the home-field advantage that they EARNED through the season (unless Bill loses early, which is certainly a possibility given that they'll have to play Jax St or Wofford). That COULD mean something in the semis.

What you think about Delaware's seeding doesn't hold much merit. Putting your insanity aside, Delaware has a weak OOC schedule, and lost two games to FCS. Both of the seeded CAA teams have two FCS losses, whereas both BSC team seeded below both CAA teams only have one. The Big Sky got hosed. Delaware should be a 4 or 5 seed.

[dbackjon]

I'm good with Appy as the 1 seed. But what I'm NOT good with is Delaware dropping two spots off of one loss. Delaware should be the 2 seed.

I know that doesn't mean much in terms of making the semis. But it DOES mean that they won't have the home-field advantage that they EARNED through the season (unless Bill loses early, which is certainly a possibility given that they'll have to play Jax St or Wofford). That COULD mean something in the semis.

What you think about Delaware's seeding doesn't hold much merit. Putting your insanity aside, Delaware has a weak OOC schedule, and lost two games to FCS. Both of the seeded CAA teams have two FCS losses, whereas both BSC team seeded below both CAA teams only have one. The Big Sky got hosed. Delaware should be a 4 or 5 seed.

Agreed. And as I posted in a thread, I blame Jim O'Day.

[PenthouseClosedEnd]

Ah what the hell, make the two Big Sky teams 1 and 2. It's not like they'll still be there to host in the semis anyway.

Well, if we could get the usual NEC or Patriot patsy's the CAA gets, then YOU BET!

Always love the first round gimme handed to the top two CAA teams.

A warm up game is always nice.

Where is that example this year? Expand.

If form holds, the CAA will be playing (1) the top MVC team, (2) Ga Southern and (3) another CAA Team in the 2nd round.